Appleby opened the extra period with a 3-pointer and Cleveland State led the rest of the way. He and Hill combined for 12 of the Vikings' 18 points in OT. Appleby made 8 of 9 free throws and six assists. Hill was 10 of 13 from the floor with four boards and four assists.
Seth Millner added 12 points for Cleveland State (10-21, 5-13 Horizon League).
Anabir's layup with 47 seconds left in regulation tied the score at 71-71. He was fouled but missed the and-one. Devin Morgan's 3-point try missed at the buzzer.
Despite the loss, Youngstown State is seeded sixth into the Horizon League Tournament. Cleveland State's season is finished.
NCAA places Miss. State on 3 years probation
Mississippi State's football and men's basketball teams will not receive postseason bans in the aftermath of an academic scandal involving a tutor.
Scouting the draft: RJ Barrett projects to be even better in the NBA
ESPN NBA draft analyst Mike Schmitz explains how RJ Barrett's circumstances might have held him back at Duke.
Memphis will hold pro day for NBA teams featuring potential lottery picks
The pro day, featuring James Wiseman and Precious Achiuwa, will have a similar format to the draft combine.